Ethics vs. Profit: Stanford's Fred Turner on the Competing Forces that Drive Innovation and the Interplay with Ethics

24 August 2023

This interview was conducted by Project Liberty's Institute as part of its effort to engage academics and build a global alliance for responsible technology to empower individuals and expand economic opportunities.

On June 16, 2023, an engaging talk co-organized by Project Liberty’s Institute and SciencesPo brought together guests from diverse backgrounds to delve into the world of cyberculture and its influence on the evolving Web3 community. Fred Turner, the Harry and Norman Chandler Professor of Communication at Stanford University and renowned author of "From Counterculture to Cyberculture," led the discussion, sharing profound insights into the past, present, and future of digital landscapes.

What is Cyberculture? Professor Turner introduced the concept of "cyberculture," a term widely used in the late 1990s to envision a new cultural landscape that would emerge with the advent of the Internet. Cyberculture represented a vision of freedom, collective voice, and expression in the digital realm, influenced by technological utopianism that had roots in the military industrial research world of the 1940s and 1950s. However, he emphasized that the initial cyberculture ideal failed to account for corporate and state interests, leading to the collision between hyper-individualism and commercial imperatives that shape today's digital landscape.

Corporate Centralization of Data in the Age of Individual Empowerment: Professor Turner highlighted a crucial aspect of the current digital ecosystem - the corporate centralization of data alongside the hyper individuation of user experiences. He unveiled the illusion of an originally free Internet and exposed how big tech companies market their technologies as tools for individual empowerment while subtly exercising control and profit. Twitter's micro-broadcasting system was cited as an example of corporate centralization intertwined with hyper individualized usership, revealing the disappearance of the middle ground.

The Legacy of Counterculture in Web3: As an alternative to centralized Web systems, the Web3 movement advocates for technical and social decentralization. Professor Turner drew parallels between the vibrant Web3 community and the legacy of countercultural movements that sought to redefine societal norms and systems. The pursuit of a decentralized and equitable digital landscape reflects the enduring influence of utopianism in technological development.

Ethical Innovation Between Design and Regulation: Embedding ethics in technology presents formidable challenges, especially when profit-driven corporate interests dominate the tech landscape. Professor Turner shared his insights on transforming the ethos of technology designers, urging them to prioritize safety over utility. He envisioned a future where technologies are better-managed to create a safer and freer world for all individuals. However, he acknowledged that the current ethical deficit within corporations hampers their ability to drive meaningful change.

To that end, he feels that we need good models which can think about the opportunities across industries and limit the negative outcomes. Only when technologies are managed, can we make the world safer and freer as it’s not simply a structural issue, it is an ethical one.

Regulation for a Safer and Freer Digital World: He stressed the importance of regulating technology, comparing it to regulating pollution in the natural world. Regulating the social media industry, akin to regulating oil and coal, is crucial to safeguarding the digital world and individual liberties. Turner emphasized the potential of Europe's regulatory efforts to shape behavior in the States, where corporate interests have heavily influenced regulatory decisions.

By understanding the interplay between counterculture ideals, corporate interests, and individual empowerment, we can pave the way for a safer, freer, and more equitable digital landscape.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter Today

Project Liberty’s newsletters keep you on the frontlines of the people, protocols and possibilities that are building a better tech future. Sign up to receive updates weekly.